Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Anthony Dickson's avatar

I agree entirely. I have been predicting this scenario for well over fifty years, since I learnt about Climate Change in yr11 geography class in 1969.

Ten years later I became a carbon farmer via native forestry. I knew that the fifty thousand Eucalypts I planted were just a futile gesture, but what were the alternatives?

I suppose I could have just continued with my legal career and invested in fossil fuel and IT.

Hmm.

Tony Dickson

William E Rees's avatar

No doubt the climate chaos predictions are on the mark and portend unprecedented catastrophe; no doubt too that some of your proposed solutions would have been quite effective if applied 50 years ago.

(That said, you omitted the need for non-coercive population policies to get human numbers down to two billion or less).

But there is another majorn structural/functional problem. You end the article by saying:

"At present, it must be clearly understood, the fossil fuels industry is knowingly trading human lives for corporate profit. It is a crime against humanity worse even than a war crime."

May I suggest it's not that simple? Modern techno-industrial (MTI) society is a product of, and remains 80%+ dependent on, fossil fuels. Fossil fuels directly or indirectly help grow, harvest, transport, process and refrigerate the bulk of the modern world's food; most of the world's long-range transportation and trade (whether by land, air or sea; whether trivial or essential) depend on fossil fuels; no major city could survive without the provisioning and waste disposal enabled by fossil fuels; most of the world's heating and increasingly essential cooling is provided directly or indirectly by fossil fuels, etc., etc.

And need I mention that modern renewable electricity (wind turbines and solar panels, W&S) are no substitute? Despite decades of impressive growth and improved efficiency, W&S currently supply only <5% of the world's energy and cannot keep up with growing demand for electricity let alone total energy.

Bottom line? Modern humanity is in a techno-culture trap. We cannot live with fossil fuels but cannot survive without them. Stopping fossil fuels rapidly would collapse the global economy and endanger billions of people; not stopping fossil fuels will destroy MTI civilization and endanger billions of people.

It's a true predicament.

80 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?